The news has sparked mixed reactions from Alice Munro’s readers, and reignited the debate on whether art can be separated from the artist. As a celebrated short story writer whose works are integral to literature modules across the world and renowned for their exquisitely drawn narratives, Munro's revelation has prompted critics to reconsider how they view her and her work.

The author of Blonde and a five-time Pulitzer Prize for fiction finalist, Joyce Carol Oates, was among those revisiting Munro’s work following the public revelation.

On X (formerly Twitter), Oates wrote, "If you have read Munro’s fiction over the years, you will notice how frequently terrible men are valorized, forgiven, and enabled. There seems to be a sense of resignation in her portrayal."

While Canadian Michelle Dean said she wished the world knew the truth sooner. “Someone will surely eventually write the piece that worries we are cancelling Munro but I feel this revelation only enriches and deepens my understanding and relationship with her work," she posted on X

The Guardian Opinions Editor Moira Donegan called out Alice Munro’s fans defending her move to stand by her daughter’s abuser. In a post on X, she wrote, “these Alice Munro women who stay with their rapist husbands because they value male approval more than solidarity with other human beings … it’s a lack of self respect so profound that I can’t pity them as brainwashed victims of patriarchy, etc. The only response is contempt.”

Kinshuk Gupta, a Delhi-based freelance journalist and Managing Editor at Usawa Literary Review, expressed that, as a reader who frequently turns to Munro for comfort, it has been the “rupture of an idealistic, benign image that makes a writer: one who has the courage to speak up, fight the duality, and imagine a more equitable world.”

“But in my limited experience, meeting a writer has failed to add another dimension to their work; instead, it has distorted it. That way, Elena Ferrante fans have a privilege. I personally stick to Eunice D’Souza’s advice: Best to meet [a poet] in a poem,” he adds in his newsletter.

While readers lamented over how the news changed their perspective of Munro and her work, A history academic, Aparna Nair, in a social media post said, “maybe it's just me, but when a horrific story about Alice Munro knowing her husband was molesting her daughter and facilitating the abuse by staying silent, and going back to him, I find it incredibly weird to see writers mourn how THEY have lost Munro. This isn't about you?”

Munro’s Books, a notable independent store in Victoria which was co-founded by Alice Munro and her first husband and Skinner’s father, released a statement expressing support for Skinner and describing her account as “heartbreaking”. The store owners stated they needed time to process the news and its potential impact on Alice Munro’s legacy, which they have long celebrated.