Court Acquits Man Accused Of Killing Labourer 9 Years Ago, Gives Him Benefit Of Doubt

The investigation officer failed to probe the case properly, Additional Sessions Judge Amit M Shete said in the order passed on March 11, a copy of which was made available on Monday.

Additional Public Prosecutor Sanjay More told the court that the accused - Hanumant Narsing Mitkar (39) and Dilip Vitthal Hadse - and victim Rajesh Bodhi Sav worked at the same construction site in Thane city and knew each other. They resided in a labour camp of the under-construction complex.

There was a change in the victim's behaviour after he returned from his hometown in Jharkhand's Sahibganj district in November 2014. Hence his roommate decided to send him back to his native place and made preparations for the same.

On November 13, 2014, before the victim could leave for his hometown, he was killed in the labour camp allegedly by the two accused after he misbehaved with the niece of one of them, the prosecution told the court.

Hadse died during the pendency of the trial and the case against him was abated. The court, while acquitting Mitkar, said the incident occurred in broad daylight, but there is no direct witness to it.

The witnesses examined are not that much relevant and do not inspire confidence, it observed. "The prosecution as well as the witnesses have failed to prove the charge beyond all reasonable doubt," the court said.

The investigation officer failed to perform his duty in investigating the crime properly, it noted. The material so collected during the investigation is not at all sufficient to hold the accused guilty of the offence of murder, the court said.

"There is absolutely no material connecting the accused with the alleged crime. In the absence of any strong and corroborative evidence, the benefit of the doubt is extended to the accused," the court said.